But Hume elaborates on sympathy to show how our affective communications can produce very different kinds of passions cf. Thus, through this descriptive account, we can grasp valuable insights as to how the relationship between human beings in a society works. Of probability; and of the idea of cause and effect. Rules by which to judge of causes and effects. The penultimate chapter of Book I of the Treatise I.

This is not sufficient for good judgment, but is required for credibility, and can provide a publicly accessible check. Pride and Sympathy in David Hume. But it is his musings on our aesthetic judgments that may provide the best example of a genuine standard of taste. Oxford Scholarly Editions Online. The introduction of the passion of pride, with its essential focus on self, shortly thereafter may bear this distinction out. Therefore, the descriptive system he proposes aims to explain how these passions arise in human beings and what effects they have in human conduct and interactions.

dissertation sur les passions david hume 1739

It also seems inappropriate to reduce passions to desires: Furthermore, he argues that this disxertation leaves room for the ability to refine one’s aesthetic palate. It works by invoking another principle, superadded to the operations of sympathy: Contents Expand All Collapse All.

Of our esteem for the rich and powerful. On this view, reason is in the business of producing beliefs, but our beliefs are relevant only to the means by which we seek to obtain those ends: According to Hume, society is an important factor to acknowledge when considering our pride.

But of all our opinions, those, which we form in our own favor; however lofty or presuming; are, at bottom, the frailest, and the most easily shaken by the contradiction and opposition of others… Our consciousness of partiality still makes us dread a mistake: Of modes and substances.


It is that general point of view that allows us to feel the distinctive sentiments of approbation grounding our moral judgments about virtue, whether artificial or natural. For these reasons, many have attributed to Hume a belief-desire model of practical reasoning, in which daviid ends are given by passions desires.

Curiosity, or love of truth falls among the direct passions, which also include desire and aversion, grief and joy, hope and fear, and somewhat oddly, volition.

A Treatise of Human Nature Series by David Hume

This is not sufficient for good judgment, but is required for credibility, and can provide a publicly accessible check. For as Alanen argues, it makes sense to think of our identity with regard to the passions as a way of corroborating whatever imperfect unity or identity the imagination supplies us, with the help of memory and association by cause and effect.

The idea of self seems, however, to be intrinsically attention-grabbing, which explains why love for another somehow connected to us readily converts into pride, but not vice-versa so I may readily feel pride when considering my children’s many accomplishments, but consideration of my own accomplishments does not tend to provoke love for my children. Oxford Scholarly Editions Online.

Of the connexion or association of ideas. Of the other qualities of our ideas of space and time. Hume took as his premise that the great diversity and disagreement regarding matters of taste had two 139 sources – sentiment, which was to some degree naturally varying, and critical facility, which could be cultivated.

Sympathy arises from our view of the situation that excites it, and puts us in the position of a spectator on that situation. Of chastity and modesty.

dissertation sur les passions david hume 1739

Division of the Subject. Sympathy vivifies that idea into an impression, that is, a passion, by borrowing from the ever-present, and lively sense of self. This section treats the narrator’s emotional landscape as a response to his skeptical conclusions about reason, sense-perception, and the self.


A Treatise of Human Nature Series

Of the amorous passion, or love betwixt the sexes. Enter the email address you signed up with and we’ll email you a reset link.

There are a variety of qualities of the good critic that he describes, each of which contributes to an ultimately reliable and just ability to judge. As to causation; we may observe, that the true idea of the human mind, is to consider it as a system of different perceptions or different existences, which are linked together by the relation of cause and effect, and mutually produce, destroy, influence, and modify each other.

Sign in or Create. Hume proposes a scale of vivacity, in which impressions are vivid, ideas are faint, and beliefs e.

Whence these objects and causes are deriv’d. Impressions can also be divided into two kinds: Now nothing is more natural than for us to embrace the opinions of other in this particular, both from sympathy which renders all their sentiments intimately present to us; and from reasoning which makes us regard their judgment as a kind of argument for what they affirm.

Of the transference of property by consent. Almost anything that invokes pleasurable impressions can be the cause of pride, within the limitations that the idea of the subject must allow us to build associative connections directing the mind to the idea of self.

dissertation sur les passions david hume 1739